Defonte's Sandwich Shop

Defonte's Sandwich Shop is a cherished Brooklyn eatery located at 379 Columbia St, where classic sandwich craftsmanship meets heartfelt neighborhood tradition. Specializing in hearty, Italian-American style sandwiches, this iconic spot has quietly curated a passionate following with its unapologetically generous portions and bold, comforting flavors.

Step up to the counter and prepare to be delighted by a menu brimming with classics and house specialties. The renowned Defontes Cuban layers tender roasted pork, ham, Swiss cheese, and pickles pressed between crusty bread, creating a harmonious blend of smoky, salty, and tangy notes. Meat lovers will swoon over the Steak Pizzaiola, where succulent steak mingles with rich tomato sauce and aromatic Italian herbs, while the Roast Beef Sandwich Dunked in Gravy offers a moist, savory experience that's the very definition of indulgence.

For those seeking a rich variety beyond sandwiches, Defonte's offers hot dishes such as Chicken Parmesan and the ever-popular Eggplant Parmesan, each plate bursting with layers of melted cheese, tender meat or vegetables, and zesty marinara. The freshness of salads like the Caprese with The Works or the hearty Light Tuna salad provide a lighter counterbalance, featuring garden-fresh ingredients that sing with authentic Mediterranean vibrancy.

The dining atmosphere is delightfully old-school Brooklyn: intimate, with standing-room-only charm that invites you to focus on what really matters—the food. Many customers reveal that a single sandwich here is so generously stuffed, it can satisfy two, making each visit a unique combination of comfort and culinary bravado.

Customer experiences shine a light on the genuine warmth Defonte's exudes. One enthusiastic patron described their Signature Hot Roast Beef and Steak Pizzaiola as an unapologetic celebration of richly layered meats, cheeses, and sauces, stacked with confident generosity. Another swears by the Golden Boy Sandwich, savoring the blend of crispy chicken cutlets, vodka sauce, prosciutto, and melted mozzarella—an unforgettable flavor marriage that keeps guests coming back. Even the humble breakfast offerings, like the egg and cheese sandwich, draw praise for their impeccable bread and satisfyingly gooey cheese pull.

In essence, Defonte's Sandwich Shop stands as a beacon of unpretentious, time-honored sandwich artistry in Brooklyn. Whether you're craving savory sandwiches bursting with personality or classic Italian-American comfort dishes, this spot delivers every time, wrapped in a cozy atmosphere and served with a friendly smile. For locals and visitors alike, Defonte's is more than just a place to eat—it's a warm, flavorful slice of Brooklyn's heart and soul.